Valerie Cascione
Golden fish and thick-cut chips with lemon on a simple ceramic plate beside a softly lit restaurant window, with open wooden tabletop to the left.

Two Doors, One Kitchen at Ossining's Brothers Fish & Chips

In January, USA TODAY published a list of 14 restaurants across the country that its food writers called worth the trip. The list ranged from barbecue to pan-Indian cooking. One pick was Brothers Fish & Chips, a seafood restaurant in Ossining. It sits at 172 North Highland Avenue, an address the Village of Ossining's 2008 news notice placed in "the shopping center next to Mavis Tire."

For Ossining residents, the national attention matters less than how the restaurant is set up. It has two entrances side by side, and both lead to the same kitchen. A Tuesday night takeout order and a seven-course tasting dinner come from the same cooks.

The Door on the Right, the Door on the Left

The restaurant's own website is direct about it. Take the door on the right for "our original quick service takeout spot." Take the door on the left for "our casual fine dining restaurant & bar." The site says the two sides are "all under one roof, all served from one kitchen and the same chefs."

The two sides are priced very differently. The current takeout menu lists bass and chips at $18 or $21 and cod or flounder and chips at $20 or $25. The largest combination platter, called All Hands on Deck, is $33. The same menu has fish ceviche for $17, fried calamari for $18, fish tacos for $23 and crab cakes for $24. In the dining room next door, the chef's tasting menu is $170 for five to seven courses of wild seafood with seasonal and local farm produce. Wine pairing is an optional $75 more.

Because both doors share one kitchen, a resident can try this cooking for the price of a fish-and-chips order before booking the full dinner. The Infatuation's Northern Westchester guide, updated on October 29 of this year, makes Brothers its Ossining pick. It notes that both the takeout spot and the full-service restaurant "serve carefully sourced, beer-battered fish and other fried marine life."

The takeout side also keeps longer hours. It is open Tuesday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., and Sunday from noon to 9 p.m. It is closed Mondays. The restaurant and bar opens at 4 p.m. and closes at 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and at 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. The takeout menu notes that items are subject to change, so call 914-488-5141 before you plan around a specific dish.

How the Takeout Counter Grew a Dining Room

The order of the two doors comes from the restaurant's history. The takeout counter came first, and Brothers did not start it. In a 2020 bilingual interview with River Journal, co-owner Elmer Oliveros said he started working at a fish-and-chips takeout shop that was already operating at this address. He and his brother Kevin bought it a few years later. They expanded into a restaurant and bar in 2015, and in 2016 Elmer added a seafood menu. The Journal News dates the restaurant to that 2016 menu and calls it "an unassuming seafood restaurant in Ossining since 2016."

In the same interview, Elmer explained that the name has two meanings. He and Kevin are the owners, and before the brothers owned the shop, customers at the counter used to call him "brother." He added that people in the community treat one another like brothers. He was born in northeastern Guatemala to parents who farmed. His mother was an excellent home cook, and his father worked in restaurants. He came to the United States at 16. He told River Journal he has no formal culinary education and that what he does in the kitchen comes from passion and years of practice. The restaurant's About page says Kevin and Elmer come from a family of chefs and that Brothers fulfills the family's dream of owning a seafood restaurant.

Elmer described an ambitious plan for the dining room in that 2020 interview. He wanted a menu of no more than a dozen simple dishes that changes with the seasons, quality wines, and a tasting menu that changes every day. In the spring of 2020, the restaurant focused on donating meals to the community. Some of those meals were paid for by customers for health care workers, and many more the restaurant gave away itself.

What the National List Saw Inside

The USA TODAY entry was written by Jeanne Muchnick of lohud and The Journal News. It describes the experience a first-time diner has here. "At first glance, you think Brothers fish store is the destination," she wrote, "until you step into the restaurant, where subdued lighting and a colorful mural set the mood." USA TODAY describes plates with fine-dining polish, often served with theatrical smoke, plus fresh edible flowers and herbs. It also describes the five-to-seven-course tasting menu, during which Oliveros explains the stories and techniques behind each dish.

A month earlier, a Journal News photo gallery shot on December 17, 2025, showed what comes out of that kitchen: ceviche, lobster bisque, shrimp croquettes and a passion fruit margarita. The Infatuation guide describes a "DIY-meets-deluxe aesthetic," a daily tasting menu that might include dishes with dehydrated chimichurri or mezcal tomato sauce, cocktails made with fresh juices, and edible flowers grown on site.

The Ossining connection reaches the fryer too. A 2023 review in The Examiner reported that the fish batter was made with beer from Sing Sing Kill Brewery, the downtown brewery and taproom. The restaurant says it goes to the fish market several times a week, changes its menu with the seasons, and buys from local and regional producers wherever it can.

The Dinners Beyond the Daily Menu

The dining room runs more than its regular menu. The most unusual event on the restaurant's calendar is the Auction Tuna Demonstration. It starts with Montauk-caught bluefin tuna, handled with a Japanese bleeding technique, graded by a fishmonger and bought at auction in the Bronx. Guests see the whole fish, can help carve it, and then eat a multi-course tasting of the different cuts with wine pairings. The page lists no fixed schedule, so ask the restaurant about upcoming dates.

Collaboration dinners happen throughout the year. This month, the restaurant scheduled a Booker Wines winemaker's dinner for November 18 with winemaker Eric Jensen of Booker Winery. Chef Oliveros planned the multi-course menu with Chef Anthony Gonçalves and Chef Ismael Fuentes of Kanopi, the restaurant on the 42nd floor in White Plains. Brothers also took part in Restaurant Week from November 2 through November 16, with a three-course lunch for $39.95 and dinner for $44.95. Both events are over by now. To hear about the next ones, join the restaurant's Diner's Club, an email list that announces specialty dinners with guest chefs, off-site events and pop-ups, and shares recipes.

A smaller weekly option is the Tuesday happy hour from 4 to 6 p.m. The cocktail list includes a Passion Margarita, a Tamarind Sour, a Brothers Negroni, house sangria and a Red Mojito. Tuesday also happens to be the first night of the week that both doors are open.

Bringing Brothers to a Gathering

Holiday hosting season is here, and the restaurant has a few options for it. Gift certificates come in $50, $75 and $100 amounts, plus a pack of three for $150 that the site suggests for neighbors, friends and family. For a bigger event, the Brothers food truck can be booked starting at $1,500 an hour. It has a two-hour minimum and a personalized menu of up to three items. Private events in the restaurant are booked through the contact form on the website.

For most people, though, the easiest way to try the cooking USA TODAY wrote about is the takeout door on a weeknight. A cod and chips for $20 or a $17 ceviche comes out of the same kitchen as the tasting menu. You can order online or call 914-488-5141.

If you're getting to know Ossining beyond Route 9, the Ossining neighborhood guide is a good next stop, along with this fall's look at the Sing Sing Prison Museum on Central Avenue. And if a place like Brothers is part of why you're picturing a life in this village, Valerie Cascione is here to help. Let's talk about your next move.

Work With Valerie

Whether working with first-time buyers or seasoned sellers, she goes above and beyond to ensure 100% satisfaction. Her clients benefit from her deep knowledge of marketing, pricing, and staging strategies, paired with her exceptional negotiation skills.

Follow Me on Instagram